Misc. · Theology

Pascal’s Wager: Stakes are High

roulette-2246562_640

 

I thought I would share a discussion I had in my college forums once concerning Pascal’s Wager. I will briefly explain the gist of this philosophy.

 

Pascal’s logic is as follows: Matters of salvation are looked at as a type of wager. The stakes are high because we are gambling with eternity and our very souls. In theory, humanity cannot fully discover knowledge of God’s existence through their own ability to reason, therefor the most prudent thing to do is to live as though God exists. This is because we have more to gain that way.

 

Pascal suggests that there are only two outcomes: 1. should God exist then those who believe in Him will win infinitely (as signified by heaven), if God doesn’t exist then believers lose nothing except for some finite things (ex. excess pleasure in life, etc). 2. Should God exist those who do not believe will infinitely lose and go to Hell, if God doesn’t exist unbelievers lose nothing. When weighing the two options the possible outcome is simply better for those who believe.

 

The first time I interacted with Pascal’s Wager was in an entry level philosophy class during my undergrad program. Recently, it has come back up in one of my theology books. It is interesting how much my perspective of the topic has changed since my early college years. At the time, I remember being floored by the sheer logic behind it. Today, I have to say that I do not find Pascal’s Wager all too convincing an argument, nor do I believe that it has any place in evangelicalism.

 

I appreciate the philosophy for what it was in its time. Indeed, Pascal’s Wager was simply revolutionary during the 17th century. It paved the way for many other philosophies. Despite this, I think there is something very flawed about viewing belief in Christ as a mere wager. There are too many errors that aren’t taken into account.

 

For one, Pascal assumes Christian belief. His wager was built on the idea of Christianity. What if someone chooses to accept the wager but applies it to a different, false God? This could lead to greater sin and punishment.

 

Also, what about God’s role in granting someone true revelation in Christ? Is that not something He does based upon His will and not our own? Pascal’s Wager asserts that those who cannot believe should “endeavor” to do so. The “fake it until you make it” philosophy might work for someone who has doubts, yet still genuinely wants to believe in Christ for unselfish purposes. However, for someone who is merely attempting to force themselves to believe based on a wager, this could just bring more anger from God.

 

There is something very dishonest and inauthentic about believing based on odds and personal gains. It certainly isn’t based on love for God but only love and concern for the self. Again by accepting this wager and claiming false conversion, you could be leading yourself to a path of greater punishment.

 

Finally, the wager suggests that a believer will lose nothing of major importance if God does not exist. This is gravely wrong. The losses a Christian should be prepared to face are not something to be brushed off lightly.  Many Christian martyrs lost their families, were tortured, and even lost their lives.

 

Have any of you come across Pascal’s Wager in your school years? What are your thoughts on this philosophy? Anyway, thanks for reading. Now, back to the books for me.

 

 

Featured photo courtesy of Pixabay.

 

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Pascal’s Wager: Stakes are High

  1. Enjoyed reading this, though I have not heard it. Similar in thought, quoting here from on of our books, “If The Holy Bible is not true, then it is a lie, and effective only to deceive those who read it. If it is true, and not a lie, then it is effective to do what God says He will do. If The Holy Bible is true, then God, the creator of man, has made His Word the authority over all things, and through the power of His own being, His Holy Spirit, He commands all things. He brings to pass what He speaks in His Word through His Son, Jesus Christ, who is the Word, the Truth, and true Life. Those who are drawn to His Word and Jesus Christ know the truth working in and through them, now and forever.” The Garden of God’s Word ~ The Purpose and Delight of Bible Study.
    Blessings ~ Fran

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree totally with this post. When I was a non believer, I found it laughable, and as a believer I find it useless. Our salvation is not a gambling wager, and I don’t think a “what if,” mentality has much place in our evangelistic conversations I will always present it as, “it is,” and what a person chooses to do with it is in fact their choice.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Pascal’s Wager presents faith as a fire insurance policy and leads to shallow, non-life changing faith. As such, it has no place in evangelism, because it does not lead to Jesus. I can see how Pascal’s Wager would be appealing to those outside the faith family, because it is a way to hedge your bets. Thanks for the thoughts!
    -Bible Bill
    http://www.pouronthecool.com

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Yes, I’ve studied this to an extent. I think that there is some truth behind what Pascal postulates in his wager. His wager is actually deceptively complex and has much to offer. Although, as you pointed out, I think that it ultimately falls short in some ways. Our faith should certainly consist of far more than a “best bet”. And I’m sure there is more to Pascals thought than these observations. I kind of see his wager as synonymous with the concept of faith itself. By this I mean we choose to have faith in God. In other words, we can’t certainly know He is real, but we have good reason to think so as and God draws us with His Holy Spirit, He requires us to make a decision to believe or not. I literally just posted an article about faith today if you wanted to check it out https://jakebyrd.wordpress.com/2017/06/14/bridging-the-gap-pt-4-the-faith-delusion/. I enjoyed reading this article, especially today while my mind is on “faith and reason”!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s